Reporting Season - Plenty of Energy but More Broadly EPS Targets Retreat
Share prices should be reflective of future expectations rather than the past. Earnings reports provide vital new information to tune expectations but on their own shouldn't dictate share prices. That is why, with the ASX reporting season now at an end, we look at changes in analysts' earnings expectations as an indicator of the strength of the season. We see these changes as far more instructive than simply whether the reported financials were better or worse than analysts' targets.
Analysts have been forecasting earnings on just under 500 ASX listed companies. In aggregate we didn't find much to get excited about. Over the course of the month of August, the average change in the consensus earnings per share forecast for fiscal 2019 was -1.76% - or -0.54% if the average is weighted by market cap.
Looking back over the past two months, capturing the impact of earnings guidance announcements made by man companies in July, the simple average EPS revision for 2019 was -1.65%, while the weighted average was +0.11%.
Figure 1: Aggregate FY19 EPS changes for ASX consensus coverage
M0/M1 = August 31 compared to July 31
M01/M2 = August 31 compared to June 30
As can be seen from Figure 1, Energy and Utilities were the sectors receiving the most favourable EPS upgrades from analysts. Energy was also the only sector where more companies received EPS upgrades than downgrades.
Equitable Investors Dragonfly Fund is a holder of IT consultancy Empired (EPD), which features in the table below (Figure 2) of the biggest EPS upgrades in August - yet its share price was unchanged. Similarly, Dragonfly Fund holds shares in fashion retailer PAS Group (PGR), which actually declined 8% despite an upgrade to analyst expectations.
Figure 2: Biggest EPS upgrades over month of August 2018 & price changes
Source: Sentieo, Equitable Investors
Thankfully, Dragonfly Fund was not a holder of any of the companies that received the heaviest downgrades from analysts, as set out in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Biggest EPS downgrades over month of August 2018 & price changes
Source: Sentieo, Equitable Investors
Analysts have been forecasting earnings on just under 500 ASX listed companies. In aggregate we didn't find much to get excited about. Over the course of the month of August, the average change in the consensus earnings per share forecast for fiscal 2019 was -1.76% - or -0.54% if the average is weighted by market cap.
Looking back over the past two months, capturing the impact of earnings guidance announcements made by man companies in July, the simple average EPS revision for 2019 was -1.65%, while the weighted average was +0.11%.
Figure 1: Aggregate FY19 EPS changes for ASX consensus coverage
M0/M1 = August 31 compared to July 31
M01/M2 = August 31 compared to June 30
As can be seen from Figure 1, Energy and Utilities were the sectors receiving the most favourable EPS upgrades from analysts. Energy was also the only sector where more companies received EPS upgrades than downgrades.
Equitable Investors Dragonfly Fund is a holder of IT consultancy Empired (EPD), which features in the table below (Figure 2) of the biggest EPS upgrades in August - yet its share price was unchanged. Similarly, Dragonfly Fund holds shares in fashion retailer PAS Group (PGR), which actually declined 8% despite an upgrade to analyst expectations.
Figure 2: Biggest EPS upgrades over month of August 2018 & price changes
Source: Sentieo, Equitable Investors
Thankfully, Dragonfly Fund was not a holder of any of the companies that received the heaviest downgrades from analysts, as set out in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Biggest EPS downgrades over month of August 2018 & price changes
Source: Sentieo, Equitable Investors