Alignment of Interest

Logic says that the managers and directors most aligned to maximising shareholder value will be those with a considerable portion of their wealth tied up in equity in the business they are involved in.

This is the 2nd grab from a brief paper Equitable Investors put together, "Seeking Advantage - Focusing on the Underlying Drivers of Excess Returns Most Evident in Smaller Companies to Optimise Investment Portfolios for Return and Risk". You can find the first grab from that paper here. And you can find the paper itself at www.equitableinvestors.com.au.

A recently published research paper reconfirmed historical studies that also showed managerial ownership leads to an improved performance. This January 2017 paper, Managerial Ownership, Board of Directors, Equity-based Compensation and Firm Performance: A Comparative Study Between France and the United States, by Bouras & Gallali, found that performance reached a maximum level at a managerial ownership level of 21.4% in the US.

The flip-side, however, is that the report found that as managerial ownership continues past this point, entrenchment appears to become an issue.

A study this author undertook in October 2012, for Investorfirst Securities, identified 38 ASX-listed companies with a CEO entitled to a larger annual dividend than their reported remuneration. Those 38 companies had achieved an average total return of 72% over the previous three years (and a median of 40%), compared to a 5.2% return for the S&P/ASX All Ordinaries Index. Only eight of the 38 had suffered negative returns in that time. The table below (lifted from that 2012 study) sets out the ten CEOs identified in that study with the highest dividend entitlement as a percentage of their executive remuneration.


Top 10 CEOs whose annual dividend entitlement most exceeded FY12 remuneration


Source: Capital IQ, Investorfirst

For CEOs to hold enough equity to earn strong dividend yields, there is a strong likelihood that they were involved in the establishment or earlier growth stages of the business. And for that reason, small and mid caps are the companies where such CEOs are most likely to be found. The average market capitalisation of the 38 companies identified was $865m at the time and the median was $222m. 

Nearly five years later we have checked how the stocks in Figure 6 have performed. The results, set out in Figure 6, are consistent with our “Alignment of Interest” thesis:

  • Only one of the ten stocks has declined in value (ASL, a mining services contractor)
  • The average total return over the period of the ten (not factoring in any reinvestment of dividends) was 70% and the median was 77%
  • This compares with a 58% total return from the S&P/ASX 100 Accumulation Index; and a 22% total return from the S&P/ASX Small Ordinaries Accumulation Index
  • The Accumulation indices assume dividends are reinvested so this comparison understates the amount by which the 10 companies have outperformed.
  • Six of the 10 outperformed the S&P/ASX 100.
  • Nine of the 10 outperformed the S&P/ASX Small Ordinaries Index.

Revisiting those Top 10 in 2017 (returns from October 2012  to July 2017)


Source: Iress, Equitable Investors

Equitable Investors Pty Ltd is a Corporate Authorised Representative (No. 001256627) and Martin Pretty is an Authorised Representative (No. 001256674) of Glennon Capital Pty Ltd (AFSL No. 338567)

Popular posts from this blog

Feel the Cash Burn as Profit Season Closes (or "In memory of Pocketmail")

Another crazy month of reporting financials has come to an end on the ASX, with the typical last minute dump of reports on the evening of August 31 (or the following morning) reflecting unfavourably on business models or financial robustness. "Have you heard if Company X has approached anyone about a convertible note or something like that", an investor peer asked me in passing on Friday. No, I hadn't. But I had looked at the financials Company X had just released and I know why he was asking. Cash on hand was equivalent to about 45% of its annual cash burn. Without fresh funding, Company X's brief life could soon come to an end. Too often founders or cornerstone investors choose to raise just enough funds to get to the next milestone, at which point they are sure investors will significantly revalue the business, allowing a less dilutive round of funding to get to the next milestone. Company X probably thought the same thing - the only problem is that its sha
Read more

We reckon equity is a key incentive

We reckon that the managers and directors most aligned to maximising shareholder value will be those with a considerable portion of their wealth tied up in equity in the business they are involved in. Earlier today we used software group Reckon (ASX code: RKN) as an example in this post on livewire. In discussing RKN, we touched very briefly on the evidence backing up our logic on equity incentive. We discuss this further in Equitable Investors' paper on the factors and inefficiencies we seek to capitalise on as part of our investment process: "Seeking Advantage - Focusing on the Underlying Drivers of Excess Returns Most Evident in Smaller Companies to Optimise Investment Portfolios for Return and Risk". You can find the paper at www.equitableinvestors.com.au or by clicking here . Or you can read our earlier blog entry on Alignment of Interest here .
Read more

New commentary up on livewire: An overlooked small cap agri stock

"When your competitors go one way, do you follow them, or do you go the other way?" That question was asked of a room of close to 100 financial advisers by keynote speaker Geoff Ramm at Centrepoint Alliance's annual conference last week. The focus at the time was effective marketing but resonated with this investment manager in a different context. The stocks that contributed most to the performance of the Equitable Investors' Dragonfly Fund in the month of September were clear cases of neglect. Investors, on the whole, had turned their focus elsewhere... Read the full article here .
Read more

Disclaimer

Nothing in this blog constitutes investment advice - or advice in any other field. Neither the information, commentary or any opinion contained in this blog constitutes a solicitation or offer by Equitable Investors Pty Ltd (Equitable Investors) or its affiliates to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments. Nor shall any such security be offered or sold to any person in any jurisdiction in which such offer, solicitation, purchase, or sale would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction.

The content of this blog should not be relied upon in making investment decisions.Any decisions based on information contained on this blog are the sole responsibility of the visitor. In exchange for using this blog, the visitor agree to indemnify Equitable Investors and hold Equitable Investors, its officers, directors, employees, affiliates, agents, licensors and suppliers harmless against any and all claims, losses, liability, costs and expenses (including but not limited to legal fees) arising from your use of this blog, from your violation of these Terms or from any decisions that the visitor makes based on such information.

This blog is for information purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice. The information on this blog does not constitute a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. Although this material is based upon information that Equitable Investors considers reliable and endeavours to keep current, Equitable Investors does not assure that this material is accurate, current or complete, and it should not be relied upon as such. Any opinions expressed on this blog may change as subsequent conditions vary.

Equitable Investors does not warrant, either expressly or implied, the accuracy or completeness of the information, text, graphics, links or other items contained on this blog and does not warrant that the functions contained in this blog will be uninterrupted or error-free, that defects will be corrected, or that the blog will be free of viruses or other harmful components.Equitable Investors expressly disclaims all liability for errors and omissions in the materials on this blog and for the use or interpretation by others of information contained on the blog.